I’VE BEEN THINKING A LOT about standardized testing since I retired from teaching in 2008. Several of the big names in education reform believe more testing is the solution. Since they’ve rarely taught, I don’t believe they even understand what the problem is.
Most teachers I know don't think focusing on testing is making education better.
Neither do I.
 |
Todd Huntly did a tour in Iraq. |
So I put out a question on Facebook for former students, asking them to tell me about teachers they felt made a difference. Their comments were excellent – and yet represent only a thin sliver of the story of U.S. education, coming only from students of the Loveland City Schools, and only from those who had me in seventh or eighth grade.
Still, these examples make me proud of what ordinary men and women accomplish every day in America's classrooms.
I should point out that I told former students I wouldn’t use anything they said about me (you know, names changed to protect the innocent, and all). Josh Nutgrass couldn’t resist, saying, “john viall is the first name that comes to mind or mrs. miranda cuz she was hot hehehe lol[.]”
Okay, Mr. Nutgrass has a good eye for the attractive female form and I must
agree; Mrs. Miranda was a very fine teacher.
Pat Treadway mentioned an old friend of mine, a former college football
player, an imposing gentleman, and a man of great integrity. Pat recalls: “Mr.
Battle. His no-nonsense attitude and toughness was a scary thing as a kid. I
look back and realize it did a lot of good for me. He also provided quality
entertainment when he saw any type of bullying or minor vandalism. I'm sure he
made a few kids pee their pants a little.”
Josh jumped back in with all caps: “O YEAH MR BATTLE ‘ASSUME THE POSITION’ OR MR MCCOY!!!”
I’m not sure which “Mr. McCoy” Josh meant, because we had three, or if he ever had to do pushups for Mr. Battle after getting in trouble, and Josh certainly wasn’t the type to be bullying anyone. But the words, “assume the position,” uttered in Mr. Battle’s deep baritone must have sent shudders up and down the spines of any bully or troublemaker who ever crossed his path at Loveland Junior High. (Later renamed: Loveland Middle School.)
Natalie Golliher cited Mr. Battle, as well, and if you can measure this kind of impact with a standardized test, I’d like to know how.
She explained:
Mr. Battle helped me get through a lot he gave me tough love when he found out I was struggling with an eating disorder everyday for weeks he walked me through the lunch line made me get a healthy meal and sat down with me and made me eat it helped with gym class being my next period after lunch so I couldn’t get out from under his eagle eye lol
We happened to have a fantastic choir director at our school, a man named Shawn Miller, and I used to sit and listen to his choir perform or go to plays he put on as director, and marvel at how he was able to coax out the talents of so many kids.
 |
Kate, left. |
Kate Altieri (in costume, above, for the musical Seussical), a senior at
Loveland High today, explained his impact:
[Mr. Miller]...doesn’t just help you with music but he can also help you
when you are...[in]need. Having six years with mr.miller ive learned so much
about myself and of course music. He is the reason I decided to major in music
education in college at northern Kentucky in the fall of 2012. He has been a
big impact on my life and I’ve never worked with such a man who
is dedicated to seven choirs, (a boys, girls, two mixed choirs, a middle
school show choir, a high school show choir and a high school top choir called
chorale) even with such a busy schedule he still makes time for his family with
havin every weekend dedicated to show choir he still puts his family first. I
want to be like Shawn miller but the girl version of course :) he is an amazing
man and an inspiring one at that too.
Kelly Harris decided to talk about an industrial arts teacher he had at
Loveland High School:
Mr. Jim Poe...is the reason my dad had me add[ed] an addition onto our house during the summer of my Junior/Senior year in high school! I have done so many home mechanics by myself that I have never needed to hire a contractor!!! I have completely rewired a house that was built in 1920, replaced roofs, completely tore out plumbing and replaced with new and even hooked up to county water as well.
Valerie Lynn Daugherty mentioned several educators who made a difference for her:
Oh there are so many... After you John [that’s me] Mr Berkoff was awesome… You both kept history interesting and fun. Doug Bush was another one of my favorites after he left I quit band which was my senior year. Mr Rich was fun but tough. Mr Miller is why I did show choir he is like Mr. Shew on Glee always made music different and ever since middle school I’ve loved singing ... Still to this day I wish I could record.
Later she
added: “Oops ... Mr. Still was another.”
Deonna Cossentino added a fresh name to the mix: “Mr. Sievering! He was
amazing, and he really connected to students. He cared for everyone, no matter
how ‘popular’ you were. He knew what needed to be done, and helped everyone who
needed it.”
I remember watching Mr. Sievering during a meeting with a young lady who was struggling in eighth grade, even though she had real talent. You can’t measure most of what teachers do, including most of what matters, but at one point during the discussion he said to her, “Jessica, what I respect about you is that you’re ‘real.’ You know who you are and you’re not afraid to show it.”
I had Jessica in class, myself, and she told me later how much kind words meant;
and when she had to tell someone she was pregnant she went to Mr. Sievering
again.
Todd Huntley spoke fondly of his foreign language teacher at Loveland High
School:
Amos Friedmann, I took 2 years of German and 1 year of French with him in high school. Looking back I can now see that he helped instill in me a love for learning about new cultures, travel, and languages. While the knowledge of German certainly came in handy living in Germany for 3+ years, it is more the interest in learning that he fostered that really set me on the path that I’m on.
Considering the fact that Mr. Huntley went on to Harvard Law, and a career in
the military (traveling to thirty countries in the process), we can safely say
that Mr. Friedman earned more than his pay.
I plan to post more examples in days to come; but I was pleased when an old
high school friend jumped in on the discussion, joined not long after by my
older brother. Mark and Tim and I are all advanced in years; but we still
remember teachers from Revere High (near Akron) who made an impact, even after
the passage of almost half a century.
That’s what great and good teachers do. They shape lives. You can’t measure
that with a chronometer, an odometer, or a standardized test. Brother Tim felt
the need to vent first, but then got into the swing:
How about Mr. -----, who made most students both hate him, and, hate algebra? What a psycho he was! On the other hand, Ms. Ocasek was great and made Latin interesting, Ms. Schmidt, my fourth grade teacher, was wonderful, and several profs I had in law school (practicing attorneys who taught in the night school) brought outstanding real-world insights to their classes!
I won’t go into details on the algebra teacher; but I had Ms. Ocasek, myself,
and when I attended my fortieth high school reunion, I asked classmates
(because this question always interests me), “Who do you remember as being a
really good teacher?”
Ms. Ocasek’s name came up a number of times, and I forgive her for giving me a “D”
in Latin II for the year. It wasn’t her fault.
I was an ignoramus back in the day.
Mark mentioned three educators who left a lasting impression:
Mr. Pamer
taught Advanced Math and Physics. He pushed us pretty hard. Any grade you got
from him was earned. He invented the concept “firm, but fair[.]” His
explanations of slippery concepts were clear and to the point. No question was
stupid, even the stupid ones. When I re-entered college in 1980, much of what
he taught still lined the inside of my skull. It lasted through my engineering
career. This is a characteristic of an excellent teacher.
Sadly,
Mr. Smith was my English teacher only for my senior year. His personality was
sometimes (how shall we say) eccentric. If you could handle the mood changes
and the occasional bombast, he was very intelligent and a great communicator.
He treated us like college students to present concepts like “death wish”,
existentialism, sexual motifs found in literature, and others. Preparing us for
college, he said, and that he did. Sometimes when I got my themes back, I
wondered if he had cut an artery over it. The grade of the paper he wrote so
large that everybody in the class saw it – there was no hiding from it.
I never took Interscholastic Basketball I, II, III from Coach Greynolds. I just
had him for Driver’s Ed. Every so often Coach tossed the Driver’s Ed book out
the window to cover what he called the practical stuff the school doesn’t teach
us. So he taught how to balance a checkbook, how to buy a new or used car, what
to look for in a house, how to apply for a loan and so forth. Was he giving us
the right scoop? In my experience, his advice was pretty sound, especially
about buying new car.
It's interesting to see how much Mark’s memories of Mr. Greynolds mirror those
of Kelly Harris, when Kelly talked about Mr. Poe. (I know dozens of former
basketball players would tell you Greynolds, the most intense coach I ever saw
in action, profoundly shaped their lives for the better.) And I can
testify myself: Eugene Smith taught me how to write – although it might
not show. (His name also came up repeatedly when I asked about good teachers at
my last high school reunion.)
Mr. Smith had one rule in class that I never forgot and adapted for use in my
own history classes (my students did a lot of writing, as I’m sure many would
attest). If he caught you using the words “thing” or “things” in an essay he
circled either and slapped an “F” on your paper and your academic goose
was pretty much cooked. If you wanted to say something, he insisted, say it
clearly. Don’t talk about “things going bad.” If your pet hamster was flattened
by a bulldozer, then by all the powers in the English language, say so!
I worked for the Loveland City Schools for 33 years and saw all kinds of
fine teachers in action, from Steve Ball, who taught math for the team of
teachers I had the honor to lead, to Jeff Sharpless, who taught seventh grade
history like I did and was always so helpful in his collaboration. I saw Rachel
Angel in action, a young lady who worked tirelessly with special education
kids, and Pat Settlemire, who got paid as an aide, but did the work of a
regular teacher, and Kathy Simpson, who worked brilliantly with LD kids.
There are hundreds of thousands of great and good teachers out there today and
there always have been. It's a shame we don't hear more about them.
*
UPDATE –
December 21, 2015: Looking at this post more than a decade later, I still
have the same doubts about the value of standardized testing.
In fact,
evidence seems to support my position: that a focus on narrow testing has
proved to be detrimental to learning, broadly defined.
Students mentioned dozens of teachers. See the following posts:
http://ateacheronteaching.blogspot.com/2012/01/why-teaching-matters-whats-square-root_07.html
http://ateacheronteaching.blogspot.com/2012/01/why-teaching-matters-whats-square-root_10.html
http://ateacheronteaching.blogspot.com/2012/01/why-teaching-matters-whats-square-root_13.html
http://ateacheronteaching.blogspot.com/2012/01/why-teaching-matters-whats-square-root_15.html
http://ateacheronteaching.blogspot.com/2012/01/why-teaching-matters-whats-square-root_15.html
