In
light of current events, I thought a few teachers might be interested in this
reading I prepared for my classes.
Feel
free to use it any way you like.
If anyone would like a copy in document form, feel free to send me an email.
You can also find many similar materials on sale at Middle School History and Tips for Teachers.
You can also find many similar materials on sale at Middle School History and Tips for Teachers.
Hiroshima and
Nagasaki
Colonel Paul Tibbets checked
last-minute details one final time. Gas gauges showed “full” and all four
engines were running smooth. Crew members reported over the intercom. Everything
was ready. Tibbets glanced at his instrument panel and pulled back on his
throttles. Slowly, his B-29 bomber, the Enola
Gay,[1]
picked up speed and headed down the runway.
More than a thousand miles to the
north, on the island of Honshu, lay the target: Hiroshima.
*
In the weeks leading up to this moment
Tibbets and members of the special 509th Bomber Group had practiced hard for
some “unknown mission.” Now the mystery had been solved. The night before
Colonel Tibbets had called his air crews together. At last, they had orders. He
could explain what their training was all about. A new type of “atomic bomb,”
he told the men, was about to be unveiled. A film of the first atomic test (on
July 16, 1945 in the desert near Alamogordo, New Mexico) was shown. Then the
lights came back up and Tibbets asked for questions. Even his veteran audience
was too stunned to respond.
When the Enola Gay rose into the sky the next morning it carried a single
bomb. It was a weapon unlike anything ever seen before. Nicknamed “Little Boy,”
it was ten feet long, 28 inches in diameter, and weighed 9,000 pounds. Most of
this weight was “machinery” to make the bomb explode. The destructive power
would come from an atomic chain reaction
unleashed inside a 22-pound lump of enriched
uranium. A little larger than a softball, this mass would generate
[produce] an explosive force equal to 20,000
tons of TNT.[2]
The men aboard the Enola Gay were about to change history;
but their five-and- a-half hour flight to Hiroshima was uneventful. As they
approached the Japanese coast a pair of escort planes could be seen checking
weather and taking film. At Tibbets’ command everyone put on special goggles to
protect their eyes. Co-pilot Robert A. Lewis was busy writing in his journal.
The bombardier, Major Thomas
Ferebee, had been “very quiet.” Then,
with the plane over Hiroshima, Lewis scribbled: “There will be a short intermission while we bomb our target.”
At exactly 8:15 a.m. on August 6,
1945 the silent Ferebee pushed his bomb switch. “Little Boy” fell away and Enola Gay rose suddenly as the weight
was released. The timing device was set to go off 45 seconds later, while the
bomb was in mid-air, hundreds of feet above the city.
The bomb worked perfectly. That is: it
was going to kill more human beings at one time than anything man had yet invented.
First there was a blinding flash of light, as if a second sun had appeared in
the sky. The fireball flashed and grew until it was a hundred yards in
diameter. Heat released by the atomic reaction was measured in thousands of
degrees.
In seconds four square miles of the
city ceased to exist. People and buildings close to the center of the blast
were reduced to vapor and ash. Stone walls a third of a mile from ground zero [the
point of explosion] melted. Across a wider area 60,000 homes, schools,
hospitals and factories were destroyed or damaged. A huge column of flame,
smoke and radioactive particles rose
high in the atmosphere. At 10,000 feet a head like a mushroom formed. The black
cloud continued rising, churning like an ugly beast. Seven miles up a second
mushroom head formed, blotting Hiroshima from view. No longer in a joking mood,
all Lewis could write was: “My God!” At
8:20 a.m. Enola Gay began turning
toward home. Tibbets broke radio silence
long enough to inform listeners at his base: “Mission successful.”
Below,
the city was a scene of unthinkable horror.
*
At the moment “Little Boy” exploded,
Dr. Masakazu Fujii was sitting at home, a mile away, looking over the morning
paper. Suddenly, a bright flash lit his page. Before he could rise from his
chair, the force of the giant blast wave sent him flying. There was a sound of
shattering glass and splintering wood. Then his house came crashing down round
him.
Toshiko Sasaki was at her desk in a
nearby factory when the bomb hit, destroying the building. Somehow, she found
herself buried under book cases and their contents. Her leg was broken, bent
almost double.
At
a nearby hospital a young doctor heard a roar and felt the building rock. Walls
and ceiling came crashing down on top of the beds. His eyeglasses were torn
from his face. Many patients and medical staff were killed instantly. Others
were badly cut by flying glass. Blood was everywhere, even on walls.
At exactly 8:15 a.m. Shigeru
Shimoyama was hard at work in his company’s warehouse. He, too, heard the blast
and felt himself flying through the air. When he came too a little later he was
impaled on a broken wood post, with
five nails stuck in his back.
Thirteen-year-old Yoshitaka Kawamoto
was at his desk in school when “Little Boy” exploded half a mile away.[3]
Before he could ask himself what the explosion was, the school was torn apart.
Two-thirds of his classmates died instantly. He was buried in wreckage, but
managed to crawl out and consider his situation. Three of his upper teeth were
broken. A piece of wood stuck in his left arm like an arrow. After rigging a
tourniquet to stop the bleeding, he began searching for survivors. A hand
sticking up led him to his best friend. The boy’s back was broken and he was
missing an eye. The two youngsters spoke a few words. Then his friend died
quietly.
With flames licking at the
splintered remains of the school, Kawamoto fled to safety. He could hear
students trapped in the ruins singing the school song to let rescuers know they
were alive. Behind him, the body of his friend stared at him with its one good
eye.
Hara Tamiki had risen from bed a few
minutes before Enola Gay released its
deadly load. Wearing nothing but shorts he headed toward his bathroom. Now the
bomb blast ripped apart his home and he felt a stunning blow to the head. When
he finally recovered his senses, he was bleeding and his shorts were gone. The
wreckage around him was on fire. So he gathered what clothes he could and fled.
In his yard he noticed a large maple tree snapped like a stick.
In every direction scenes of horror
filled the view. Four thousand soldiers of the Japanese Second Army, stationed
near the center of town, had been wiped out. A handful of U. S. airmen, shot
down during an earlier raid and held in the city castle, were incinerated. Countless civilians were
horribly burned or buried in wreckage. As survivors scrambled from the ruins,
they could hear screams for help from beneath the rubble. Fumio Shigeto, for
one, was “lucky.” At the moment “Little Boy” exploded he was standing in line
for a trolley car. Everyone in front was burned to death by the fireball.
A corner of a building shielded
Shigeto and he survived.
The people of Hiroshima had no idea
what hit them. Many were in shock. Others were so badly injured they could not
have cared what kind of weapon had been used—even if someone could have
explained how the atomic bomb worked. Terrified and confused, some cried out
that more planes were coming with more of these awful bombs.
With hospitals, fire and police
stations destroyed, survivors headed for the banks of the Ota River. Others
stumbled out of the city in search of safety or simply fled the hell around
them. Reverend Kiyoshi Tanimoto saw hundreds of victims streaming along the Koi
Highway. “The eyebrows of some were
burned off and skin hung from their faces and hands. Others, because of the
pain, held their arms up [away from their burned bodies] as if carrying
something in both hands...Many were naked or in shreds of clothing.”
Michiko Yamakoa, a 15-year-old schoolgirl, was among those headed for the
countryside. Spotting a friend, she called to her, but at first the other girl could
not recognize her. “Your nose and
eyebrows,” she explained, “are gone.”
By 9:00 a.m. Shigeru Shimoyama had
pulled loose from the nails in his back and headed for the river. Along the way
he saw a sight he would never forget. Before him was a pink horse, standing,
head down, its skin seared off. The
beast looked at him as he passed—tried to follow—but could not.
Other survivors uncovered Toshiko
Sasaki from the piles of books in her wrecked office. There was no time to
treat her smashed leg. They left her under a shed with two other victims. One
was a woman whose chest was crushed. The other was a man burned so badly his
face looked like a tomato. Nearby, a young mother clutched a dead child and
begged passers-by to find her husband. “You’ve
got to find him,” she sobbed. “He
loved our baby so much. I want him to see her once more.”[4]
In a park along the river, Reverend Tanimoto stopped to assist others. As he
lifted one burned woman from a boat, “her
skin slipped off in huge glove-like pieces.” Working amid scenes of horror
he had to keep reminding himself: “These are human beings.”
Many who survived the blast and
flames began dying that night from radiation
sickness. Seven-year-old Shizuko Iura neared death. Still, she had strength
to try to comfort her mother. Shizuko’s father, a soldier, was stationed far
away from home. Now the little girl pleaded, “Please stay alive, Mother. If both of us die, he will be very lonely.”
She spoke briefly about friends and relatives she loved, called out, “Papa! Papa!” and died.
The toll on this day was 90,000
killed.
Two of the lucky survivors. |
*
Even in the face of vast destruction
the Japanese hesitated to surrender. On August 9, a second atomic bomb fell on
the city of Nagasaki. There surrounding hills cushioned the blast and loss of
life was not quite so terrible. Still, the destruction was staggering. Again a
brilliant ball of flame appeared over the doomed city. Then there was a roar, “as though the sky were being scooped out
with a sharp tool.” High overhead, the American co-pilot studied the awful
scene below. Then he called back to bombardier Kermit K. Beahan, “Well, Bea, there’s a hundred thousand Japs
you just killed.” Later a Japanese author summed it up grimly: “A large city had disappeared in a
twinkling, from one explosion.”
The fate of Nagasaki was awful.
Those exposed to the fireball were roasted. Thousands were trapped in smashed buildings.
Fires whipped by high winds spread flames in all directions. Fujie Urata had
left her mother earlier that morning to go for a visit. Now she raced back to
find her house gone and her mother dead. The pumpkin field in front of the home
was blown clean. Nothing remained, except a woman’s head where the pumpkin crop
had been. A gold tooth gleamed from the wide open mouth. Fujie could not
recognize the victim.
Elsewhere, Fujie’s sister, Tatsue,
saw a woman burned till “her face was one
blister,” holding two equally scarred children. The blinded mother begged
Tatsue to take them; but the girl knew all three would soon be dead. In another
burning neighborhood a mother “rushed
around half-crazy, trying to find [her daughter] until she was overcome by
smoke and collapsed.” She suffered serious burns but could not rescue the
girl. By a twist of fate, the same woman’s husband had been visiting Hiroshima
three days before and died there.
Once more, a large part of the city
was pulverized, and survivors fled into the surrounding countryside. One boy
saw them coming along a road and remarked that the burned people “looked like a parade of roast chickens.”
Another girl, who tried to enter the city to reach her home, asked all passing
women if they had seen her mother. Many were blistered and unrecognizable and
might have been her mother! As at
Hiroshima the explosion was followed in some areas by large greasy raindrops.
High above, moisture surrounding the pillar of smoke and hot dust was
condensing and falling like black rain.
Nagasaki was reduced to “a hill of ashes.” Where once had stood
a great city nothing remained but charred bodies and white ash. Thousands were
dead, more thousands injured. Yet the dying would not end quickly, even after
Japan finally agreed to surrender.
As the days and weeks passed,
countless victims died in agony. Often, the cause was radiation poisoning.[5] Symptoms,
though not always fatal, varied.
Many victims lost their hair and suffered from high fever and diarrhea. Blood
disorders might develop. Sores broke out all over the body. Wounds refused to
heal. Men were made sterile. Pregnant women miscarried. One nine-year-old boy
who survived the attacks remembered watching his mother slowly die. Thirteen days
after Hiroshima was hit, her hair had fallen out. There was a deep wound in her
back which never closed and her breathing was labored [difficult; hard work].
One day he tried to feed her a little soup. She struggled to swallow, took a
last breath, let it out, and her suffering was ended forever.[6]
*
In the weeks and months to come men
and women round the world paused to wonder. What would future wars be like if one
side—or both—employed these terrible tools of death? In the days following the
attacks at least one survivor interrupted a priest who was offering support. “If your God is so good and kind,” he
asked angrily, “how can he let people
suffer like this?”
Perhaps the two atomic bombs had to
be used. Perhaps not.
There
was disagreement then. There still is.
Whatever the case war, and mankind’s
future, changed forever during those grim days of August 1945. The shadow of
the mushroom cloud has darkened humanity’s path ever since.
Your
work:
1.
Pretend you were in Hiroshima or Nagasaki when the bombs hit. Write about what
happened to you, your neighbors, family and friends.
[1]
The plane was named after Tibbets’ mother.
[2]
At the time the United States had only two atomic bombs ready for use. Because
their designs were different they were tagged with nicknames to suit them. A
shorter, thicker bomb was called “Fat Man.”
[3]
Normally, Kawamoto remembered, students looked forward to air-raid warnings. At
such times they were allowed to stop work and seek a safer spot.
[4]
The poor woman refused to give up the dead child for four days.
[5]
Japan agreed to stop all fighting on August 15. A peace treaty was signed on
September 2, 1945.
[6]
Counting those who died from lingering affects like cancer, many ten or twenty
years later, the toll at Hiroshima is said to have reached 138,000. Losses at
Nagasaki were probably around 49,000. By comparison the terrorist attacks
against the United States on September 11, 2001 killed about 3,500.
My problem: You fail to provide a balanced lesson:
ReplyDeleteThe Japanese invaded China - they raped (The Rape of Nanking), looted, killed and enslaved tens of thousands of innocent Chinese, Japanese prison of war camps were incredibly cruel, and an invasion of Japan would have resulted in 250,000 American casualties, and, Russia was preparing to invade the Japan, if you were a an adviser to President Truman in 1945 would you have recommended and invasion or the use of atomic bombs or another policy .... write a memorandum to the president advocating a policy to end the war.
While you clearly oppose the dropping of the bombs I believe our role to encourage our student to explore options, collect data, and draw and defend conclusions .... in spite of our personal views.
This comment has been removed by the author.
DeleteThe lines near the end pretty much sum it up: "Perhaps the two atomic bombs had to be used. Perhaps not. There was disagreement then. There still is."
DeleteI don't "clearly oppose" the dropping of the bombs and know all about the sins of the Japanese. I only want students to realize how horrific these weapons are.