Sunday, September 22, 2019

1948

__________ 

“…a kind of mindlessness that was special to the period…” 

David Halberstam speaking of the anti-communist rhetoric of the era.

__________


 

“HARRY TRUMAN was a success in the White House partly because he was openly, joyously and unabashedly Harry Truman; he was what he was, he gloried in attacks on his inadequacies, they being in general the inadequacies of most normal men, and he made his limitations his assets…”  (Halberstam, forgot to note page)

 

NOTE TO TEACHERS: Most of my students had never heard of President Truman. It always worked to show them this famous picture and ask them why this photo from the 1948 presidential election was famous. (If I had a kid who seemed to know, I wouldn’t call on him or her – or now, “they” – until we had several “wrong” answers. I liked to use Truman’s story of persevering in 1948, as an example for my classes.  

See descriptions of the campaign below.

 

I was a do-nothing dope in school, myself, and only learned the importance of perseverance later in life. For example: at Parris Island. 

  

* 

I.F. STONE paints a grim picture in his book The Truman Era. (By comparison, this blogger is a big Truman fan – but aware of the dangers of the period.) 

    Explaining his reasons for fighting for freedom, which he saw as under attack, he wrote, “The place to be is where the odds are against you; power breeds injustice, and to defend the underdog against the triumphant is more exhilarating than to curry favor with those on top and move safely with the mob.” 

    “These were the years which saw the beginnings of the Cold War and of the drive toward intellectual regimentation in America.” 

    Stone refers to Truman as a “mediocre president,” and paints a picture of the mediocrities who fill Congress: 

The composite impression was of big-bellied good-natured guys who knew a lot of dirty jokes, spent as little time in their offices as possible, saw Washington as a chance to make useful “contacts,” and were anxious to get what they could for themselves out of the experience. They were not usually corrupt or especially wicked … The Truman era was the era of the moocher. The place was full of Wimpys [a character in Popeye cartoons] who could be had for a hamburger.

 

    He also warned readers that, “Big Business planned to establish a glacial conformity, a chrome-plated American version of what George Orwell saw ahead for mankind.” 

    “There are moments when the traditions of liberty seem to exercise very little real hold upon the American mind,” he warned while also warning against “that often most intolerant of despotisms, the majority itself.” 114/xix-xxiv 

    Stone also lambasts “the backwoods bird-brains of the House Un-American Activities Committee.” 114/48


* 

February: A Communist coup, as Goldman writes, “sucks Czechoslovakia under The Iron Curtain, recalling to the least-informed Americans memories of Munich, 1938.” 

    Russia appears ready to take control of Finland. Italian elections are coming in April and newspapers in the United States agree that the Communists have at least a 50-50 chance to win. 

 

“Fear of what? Most people don’t know exactly.” 

President Truman appeared before his press conferences making little pretense of chipperness. His faith in ultimate world peace, the President admitted, was being shaken. Reports went out that Secretary of Defense James Forrestal was meeting in Key West with heads of the Army, Navy, and Air Force to iron out their roles in the event of fighting. Two Republican members of the house, Charles Kersten of Wisconsin and Richard Nixon of California, expressed an attitude rapidly spreading in Congress. They presented a resolution giving “solemn warning to the conspiracy in the Politburo that any further step of aggression, internal or external, will be actively resisted by every means at our disposal.”

 

Throughout the country war fears ran rampant. In New England, “wait until the Russians hit” and “when we fight Stalin” were becoming clichés. In Atlanta, friends were greeting each other with: “Well, boy, break out that old uniform.” A Seattle newspaper summarized: “Generally, people here have come to feel that war is definitely on the way.”

 

A Chicago reporter caught the national mood in its fuller nuances. “Cold fear is gripping people hereabouts. They don’t talk much about it. But it’s just as real and chilling as the current 11-degree weather. Fear of what? Most people don’t know exactly. It’s not fear of Russia alone. For most think we could rub Joe’s nose in the dirt. It’s not fear of Communism in this country. Few think there are enough Commies here to put it over. It’s not fear of the atom bomb. For most think we still possess a monopoly. But it does seem to be a reluctant conviction that these three relentless forces are prowling the earth and that somehow they are bound to mean trouble for us. Not many months ago, these forces were something to be thought about only in off moments—like when you turned in some commentator by mistake….But all winter, confidence in peace has been oozing away. With the Czech coup , it practically vanished.” (1/78-79)

 

* 

“That was the most beautiful music I have ever heard.” 

Baseball season: The New York Times had a good story about Maybelle Blair, who came out as a lesbian, at age 95, in 2022.

In 1948, Blair was playing softball in Redondo Beach, California, when a scout for the All-American Girls Professional Baseball League saw her play. He wanted to sign her; but her mother resisted. When she found out Maybelle would be making $55 per week she put her on the train to Chicago. 

In her “early 90s,” the Times noted, Blair once visited a sporting goods store and asked to try on a pair of baseball cleats. Once the salesman realized she was serious, he brought her a pair. 

“He put them on my feet. I got up and marched around, and I heard that clicketyclack in my head and I was never so happy,” Blair said.

 

After taking the cleats for a walk in the store, Blair took them off, put them in their box and told the salesman that she wouldn’t be taking them.

 

“That was a big thrill of my life, just to put cleats on and march again,” she said.

 

For Blair, the sound of cleats brought back memories of suiting up as a Peoria Redwing and walking onto the field, her favorite baseball ritual.

 

“I was so proud of myself because it dawned on me: I got to play the game I loved and cherished,” she said. “I’d put on my spikes and march down the aisle and walk onto the field, clicketyclack, clicketyclack. That was the most beautiful music I have ever heard.”

 

Blair was one of more than 600 women to join the baseball league, created in 1943 in response to World War II. As young men were drafted, fears spread that the war would be the demise of professional baseball and its ballparks. So women played instead.

 

Blair first began to become aware of her sexuality in fifth grade, and her first love came when she was a senior in high school. “I’ll never forget her,” she said. But she kept her relationships private and never married.

 

“I was so worried about my family because in those days nobody knew anything about people being gay or what have you. It was so nerve-racking,” she said.

 

She found herself happiest on the field. Blair, who grew up in Texas and California, said she was “born a baseball fan.”

Image

 

“If I hadn’t, my father would have gotten rid of me,” she said with a laugh. “Playing baseball was the only entertainment we had besides breaking horses.”

 

* 

THE ACRONYM “WASP” for white, Anglo-Saxon Protestants first appears in the New Amsterdam News. WASPs were once rightly described as “America’s original ruling class.” 

 

* 

“Carry as little as possible. But choose that little with care.” 

April 4: Earl Shaffer, a WWII veteran, sets out to become the first person to walk the Appalachian Trail in one continuous hike. When his tent proves too cumbersome, he ditches it and sleeps in a poncho for the next 124 days. One pair of Russell Moccasin Company boots got him all the way through. He carried a little notebook to record impressions. “The fact that he was carrying those extra five or six ounces showed how important it was to him,” says Jane Rogers of the National Museum of American History. 

Today about 1,000 thru-hike the trail each year; 3,000,000 walk portions. (His entire journal is online.) Having served four years in the Pacific, he said he set out to “walk the war out of my system.” He passed the battlefield at Antietam, met other veterans out hiking and talked to a farmer whose son “was psycho from [the] army.” Twice, he mentions Walter, a childhood friend, in his journal. Walter had dreamed of walking the trail with him someday, but he was killed at Iwo Jima. 

Shaffer became the oldest person, at 79, to hike the entire trail in 1998. 

That record was broken in 2017, when Daniel “Greybeard” Sanders completed the thru-hike at age 82.


A recent hiker on the trail.

 

I had a good number of students who enjoyed reading Bill Bryson’s book, A Walk in the Woods, about his own hike. 


NOTE TO TEACHERS: You can find a copy of a reading list of several hundred books I used in my class. I retired in 2008, but add a few books every year.

*

 

Summer: Lt. James W. Becton Jr., an African American officer serving in the U.S. Army reserves, listens as his base commander reads President Truman’s executive order desegregating the military. 

Becton would eventually rise to the rank of lieutenant general, but explained how he felt at that time: 

“‘As long as I am the commander here, there will be no change,’” he recalled the base commander saying. “I didn’t believe what I heard,” he added in an interview with The Washington Post in 2018. “This was the commander in chief saying this is what it’s going to be. But here was a commander saying nothing would change.”

  

* 

June 24: The Berlin Air Life begins. The New York Times highlights the contributions of Lt. Gail S. Halvorsen, the original “Candy Bomber” of the operation. 

Lt. Gail S. Halvorsen, an Air Force transport pilot, was on the grounds of West Berlin’s Tempelhof airfield on a mid-July day in 1948, taking part in a historic confrontation of the early Cold War years, when he spotted some 30 German children in ragged clothing outside a fence.

 

He reached into his back pocket, extracted a pack of Wrigley’s Doublemint and handed out the last two sticks of gum in the pack.

 

“The look in their eyes, I could see their appreciation for something so small,” he recalled long afterward. “I wanted to do something more, so I told them to come back later.”

 

Halverson promised to drop more candy the next day, when he flew in from his base near Frankfurt. The children asked how they would know which plane he was flying. “I told them I’ll wiggle the wings.” 

In the months to come, an act of kindness by this American airman — the boys and girls of West Berlin would come to call him Uncle Wiggly Wings — grew into a storied good-will operation within a Great Powers drama.

 

Lieutenant Halvorsen and his two crewmen joined with fellow American airmen to drop a total of 23 tons of candies, chocolate and chewing gum wrapped in tiny parachutes from their planes while preparing to touch down at Tempelhof airfield with vast quantities of other supplies in an effort to break a Soviet land blockade of Berlin’s Allied-occupied western sectors.

 

The Times notes that the airlift represented not only “a defiance of Soviet power by the United States, Britain and France,” but “also symbolized reconciliation between the German people and the Allies in the wake of World War II.” Only three years before, Allied warplanes and left German cities in ruins. 

The airlift began after the Soviet Union cut off the Allied powers’ land access to West Berlin, situated deep inside Soviet-controlled East Germany, in June 1948. The people of West Berlin were faced with near starvation and an impending winter without fuel.

 

The airlift, which continued for 15 months, claimed the lives of 31 American airmen and 39 British fliers in accidents, but it thwarted the Soviet leader Joseph Stalin’s attempts to drive the West from the city. By the time it ended in September 1949 (the Soviet blockade had been lifted the previous May), Allied pilots had flown more than 277,000 missions, sometimes buzzed by Soviet fighters, to supply the city’s western sectors with 2.3 million tons of food, flour, coal, medicine and construction equipment.

 

Lieutenant Halvorsen, a native of Utah, flew 126 Berlin airlift missions, joined by his co-pilot, Capt. John Pickering, and his navigator, Sgt. Herschel Elkins.

 

In September 1948, the Air Force sent Lieutenant Halvorsen back to the United States to publicize his efforts, and he appeared on the CBS-TV program “We the People.” American candy manufacturers began donating sweets, and schoolchildren volunteered to wrap them in simulated parachutes, made from handkerchiefs and twine, for shipment to Allied-occupied West Germany.

 

Lieutenant Halvorsen received many letters from German children during the airlift.

 

A 9-year-old named Peter Zimmerman sent him a homemade parachute and a map providing directions to his home for a candy drop. Lieutenant Halvorsen searched for the house on his next flight but couldn’t find it. … Peter sent another note reading: “No chocolate yet. … You’re a pilot. … I gave you a map. … How did you guys win the war anyway?”

 

Lieutenant Halvorsen sent Peter a chocolate bar in the mail.

 

“Gail Halvorsen enchanted the children of Berlin,” recalled Ursula Yunger, who had been one of those children and later settled in the United States. “It wasn’t the candy,” she told The Tucson Citizen in 2004. “It was his profound gesture, showing us that somebody cared.”

 

Halvorsen earned a private pilot’s license in 1941, joined the Army Air Force after briefly attending college, and earned his wings in 1944. He hoped to see combat, “but he was assigned to ferry bombers and transport planes across the South Atlantic for the European and North African campaigns.”

 

* 

July 10: With Truman’s approval ratings tanking, some panicked Democrats consider drafting Eisenhower to run for the presidency. 

    He sends back this reply: “No matter under what terms, conditions, or premises a proposal might be couched, I would refuse to accept the nomination.”

 

* 

July 11: A group of whites and blacks visited Druid Hill Park, in Baltimore, “to stage an inter-racial tennis combat, and were collared and jugged by the cops,” says H.L. Mencken. He later condemns the arrest, as well as the policy behind it: 

A free citizen in a free state, it seems to me, has an inalienable right to play with whomsoever he will, so long as he does not disturb the general peace. If any other citizen, offended by the spectacle, makes a pother, then that other citizen, and not the man exercising his inalienable right, should be put down by the police.

 

Certainly it is astounding to find so much of the spirit of the Georgia Cracker surviving in the Maryland Free State, and under official auspices. The public parks are supported by the taxpayer, including the colored taxpayer, for the health and pleasure of the whole people. Why should cops be sent into them to separate those people against their will into separate herds? Why should the law set up distinctions and discriminations which the persons directly affected themselves reject? If the park tennis courts were free to all comers no white person would be compelled to take on a colored opponent if he did not care to… No one could be invaded in his privacy. Any white player could say yes or no to a colored challenger, and any colored player could say yes or no to a white. But when both say yes, why on earth should anyone else object?

 

It is high time that all such relics of Ku Kluxry be wiped out in Maryland. The position of the colored people since the political revolution of 1895, has been gradually improving in the State, and it has already reached a point surpassed by few other states. But there is still plenty of room for further advance…The Park Board rule is irrational and nefarious. It should be got rid of forthwith.

 

Of equal, and maybe even worse, irrationality is the rule regarding golf-playing on the public links, whereby colored players can play on certain links only on certain days, and white players only on certain other days. (49/227-230) 

 

* 

“The status of a mongrel, inferior race.” 

July 17: At a convention of “states’ rights” Democrats, former Alabama Gov. Frank M. Dixon blasts President Truman. Speaking for the white folk of the South, Dixon warns that Truman’s effort to advance civil rights for black people will “reduce us to the status of a mongrel, inferior race.” 

Attendees then nominate South Carolina’s Gov. Strom Thurmond to run under a Dixiecrat Party label in the race to become the next President of the United States. The party platform pledges to protect “the segregation of the races and the racial integrity of each race.”

 

* 

July 26: Mencken also has an opinion regarding Henry Wallace, the former vice president: “Soak a radio clown for ten days and ten nights in the rectified juices of all the cow-state Messiahs ever heard of and you have him to the life.”


Same day: President Truman announces in an Executive Order that it shall be “the policy of the President that there shall be equality of treatment and opportunity for all persons in the armed services. This policy shall be put into effect as rapidly as possible, having due regard to the time required to effectuate any necessary changes without impairing efficiency or morale.” 

Sen. Thurmond explodes. “There’s not enough troops in the Army,” he warns, “to break down segregation and admit the Negro into our homes, our eating places, our swimming pools and our theaters.” In fact, interracial marriage would be banned in several states for another nineteen years. 

Racial purity was said to be at stake. 

Ironically, it turned out decades later that segregation and racial purity had already ended in Strom Thurmond’s pants. When he was 23, in 1925, he fathered a child by Carrie Butler, his family’s black maid. 

Butler was 15 at the time.

 

* 

August 23: In a speech to Europeans, John Foster Dulles suggests that the threat of communism must be met, insisting, “at times, war may have to be risked as the lesser of two evils.” 

    I.F. Stone responds: “I do not want to hear Dulles say at Amsterdam that man is created in the image of God. I want to hear him say it in Atlanta, Georgia, when one of those images, done in charcoal, has been strung up to a tree.” 114/125 

    On August 23, Stone notes that “the Southern Negro exists in a twilight between slavery and freedom.” 114/130 

    “If the Negro continues to get off the sidewalk,” Stone adds, “he can never expect to stand upon it as an equal. The Negro himself will determine just how long he is going to go on being treated as a ‘nigger.’” 114/132 

 

* 

September: Martha Mason, age 11, goes to bed one night, feeling achy. As The New York Times later explained, “She did not tell her parents because she did not want to compound their sorrow: that day, they had buried her 13-year-old brother, Gaston, who had died of polio a few days before.” 

    Whatever strain had killed Gaston, it was probably the same that paralyzed Martha from the neck down. “Martha spent the next year in hospitals before being sent home in an iron lung. Doctors told her parents she would live another year at most.” 

    They were wrong, however, for she would live another sixty years, her “home” a “7-foot-long, 800-pound iron cylinder that encased all but her head.” Despite the limits imposed on her, she would later describe her life as fine and full,  

    She survived, she later said, because she was endlessly curious and there was so much to learn.

 

    With daily visits from her teachers, Martha resumed her studies, graduating first in her high school class. She entered Gardner-Webb College in Boiling Springs, N.C., receiving an associate’s degree in 1958.

 

    Afterward, Ms. Mason and her iron lung were transported by bakery truck to Winston-Salem, where she enrolled in Wake Forest College. There, she joined a student group seeking to integrate the campus. She earned a bachelor’s degree in English from Wake Forest in 1960.

 

    At both colleges (they are now universities) Ms. Mason lived with her parents in a campus apartment and attended lectures by intercom. At both colleges, she graduated first in her class.

 

    Returning to Lattimore, Ms. Mason began writing for the local newspaper, dictating her articles to her mother, Euphra. Not long afterward, Ms. Mason’s father, Willard, suffered a major heart attack and became an invalid, requiring Euphra to care for him, too. There was no more time for taking dictation. For decades afterward, Ms. Mason wrote only in her head, publishing nothing. Her father died in 1977.


    Perhaps only in a place like Lattimore, whose current population is not much more than 400, could Ms. Mason have thrived as well as she did. For if Ms. Mason could not go to the town, then the town was quite prepared to come to her. The doctor visited regularly, of course, but so did all the neighbors and the neighbors’ neighbors. So did members of the local fire department, who came by during power failures to make sure her backup generator was working.

 

    Ms. Mason often gave dinner parties (she ate lying down, with her guests around the table and the iron lung pushed up beside it) and savored lively conversation, good gossip and the occasional bawdy story. Amid the rhythmic whoosh ... whoosh of the iron lung, the local book club met in her home. High school graduates stopped by so she could admire them in their caps and gowns, as did just-married couples in their wedding finery. Souvenir magnets from faraway places, gifts from traveling friends, adorned the yellow exterior of Ms. Mason’s iron lung like labels on a steamer trunk.

 

    But small-town life could have its drawbacks. “She’s an intellectual, yet the local video store was not going to have ‘Wild Strawberries’ for her to rent,” Ms. Dalton, an associate professor of communication at Wake Forest, said in a telephone interview on Wednesday. “She could talk to anybody, but she needed that kind of intellectual stimulation, too. And there were years when I imagine that was a little hard to come by.”

 

    That changed in the mid-1990s, when Ms. Mason acquired a voice-activated computer with e-mail capability and Internet access. The computer brought her the world. It also let her contemplate writing her memoir, which is subtitled “Life in the Rhythm of an Iron Lung.”

 

    She began the book in tribute to her mother. In the late 1980s, after a series of strokes, Euphra Mason descended into dementia and abusiveness, occasionally slapping and cursing her daughter. Ms. Mason insisted that her mother remain at home. From her iron lung, she took over the running of the household, planning meals, paying bills and arranging for her mother’s care.

 

    After her mother’s death in 1998, Ms. Mason began work on her book in earnest. There, in her childhood home, with a microphone at her mouth and the music of the iron lung for company, she wrote her life story sentence by sentence in her soft Southern voice, with her own breath. 

 

* 

September: The campaign for president is in its final stages. Goldman explains: 

[Thomas] Dewey campaigned six weeks; Truman, eight. Dewey covered 16,000 miles; Truman, 22,000. Dewey made 170 speeches; Truman, 271. Up and down the country the President went, clambering out of the confusion of his campaign train to talk to any crowd that gathered at 7 a.m. or 11 p.m. “Give ‘em Hell, Harry,” somebody would yell and Harry Truman, the Missouri twang shrill, both hands pumping up and down, would pour it on in the roughest English spoken by a presidential campaigner since frontier days. So Dewey was proud of the Republican Party? Those fellows are just a bunch of old mossbacks …gluttons of privilege…all set to do a hatchet job on the New Deal.” So Dewey was above mentioning Truman’s name? “That’s all a lot of hooey. And if that rhymes with anything, is not my fault.” So the real issue in the campaign was unity? Dewey “is talking mealy-mouthed political speeches.…I warn you...if you let the Republicans get control of the government, you will be making America an economic colony of Wall Street.” (1/84-85)

 

People talked about Truman, fighting it out. “Mighty game little scrapper,” they said. But it was expected he’d lose. 

Elmo Roper had long since stopped taking public-opinion polls; two months before election day science declared the election over. Leading Democratic politicians, students of another science, were publicly offering their Washington homes for sale. Bookies quoted odds they would have refused on Joe Louis at his prime – fifteen-, twenty-, even thirty-to-one. (1/86)

 

* 

November 2-3: Goldman has a great description of that election night: 

     Until 9:00 or so Truman was leading in the popular and in the electoral votes. This was as expected, the radio commentators explained; wait until the rural returns came in. By ten o’clock a good many of the farm areas were reporting. The figures were not particularly Republican, while Truman went on rolling up majorities in the cities. The voices of the commentators were as authoritative as ever; wait until there were enough rural returns to show the inevitable pattern. The Chicago Tribune, no journal for shilly-shallying, was out on the streets with its extra:

 

DEWEY DEFEATS TRUMAN

 

     Some people stayed up. Ten-thirty, eleven, eleven-thirty – chairs hunched closer to the radio, conversation was shushed, somebody would dart off to telephone and wake up a friend. The Dixiecrats were carrying only three or four states in the South and Henry Wallace was showing no real strength except in California and New York. The Truman majorities in the cities remained substantial and the farm areas were reporting slim Dewey victories or Democratic sweeps. H.V. Kaltenborn of NBC, the voice that had reported Munich, 1938 to America, the voice that had been news incarnate to a large part of a generation, kept saying, crackling and definitive, wait until the full rural returns come in. But the litany was breaking. On the ABC network George Gallup was a shattered man. He could only sigh and tell his audience: “I just don’t know what happened.”

 

     Later and later the lights burned in living rooms. It was clear that Truman was holding most of the South and a sizable bloc of Midwestern and Western states. … By dawn the issue was California, New York, or Ohio; the electoral votes of any one of these states would push the Democrat over. New York, with Wallace taking a half million votes from Truman, went Republican. California and Ohio swung crazily back and forth, with majorities of fifteen hundred this way, twenty-five hundred the other, in states that had well over two million voters apiece.

 

     At breakfast time the Ohio results became definite. After a long twenty minutes, Harry Truman came out of his Kansas City hotel suite. The strut of the bantam cock was gone; the eyes were misty. The President and President-elect of the United States walked slowly into the lobby, arm in arm with his brother Vivian, and reporters overheard him whisper tremulously: “I just hope – I hope so much I am worthy of the honor.”

 

Experts were stunned (one is reminded of the feeling we had in 2016). Voter turnout had been heavy. The country had been ready to remove Truman. “But then a vast swing had set in – a swing which came so late thousands said they had walked into the polling places intending to vote Republican and had ended up casting a Democratic ballot.” (1/88) 

 “I kept reading about that Dewey fellow,” said Charles Crenshaw of New Lebanon, Ohio, “and the more I read the more he reminded me of one of those slick ads trying to get money out of my pocket. Now Harry Truman, running around and yipping and falling all over his feet – I had the feeling he could understand the kind of fixes I get into.” (1/89) 

 

* 

JAMES EARL JONES, 17, a high school student in Michigan, of mixed African American and Irish ancestry, is slowly discovering his voice. In his early youth, he had developed a severe stutter and had remained mute. 

    When Jones was in high school, a poet and former college professor named Donald Crouch persuaded him to break his silence. After the teacher introduced him to the poems of Henry Wadsworth Longfellow, Jones wrote an ode to grapefruit patterned after Longfellow’s “Song of Hiawatha.” In what might have been a bid to make the boy speak, Crouch said the poem was so good that it must have been plagiarized — a notion Jones could only dispel by reading it aloud. It turns out that poetry, like song, can help stutterers overcome disfluency, and in performance Jones found himself able to speak. Jones went on to participate in school competitions and recitals, sometimes reading lines of Edgar Allan Poe’s verse. As he discovered his voice, he gravitated toward anything that required him to use it: public speaking, debate, oratory contests.

 

    As for that voice, Jones would go on to great success in plays and on film, including playing the voice of Darth Vader in the Star Wars films.

 

* 

December 20: In an essay titled “Mein Kampf with the (Lily-White) National Press Club, the journalist I.F. Stone describes his attempt to bring a Negro to lunch at the club: 

    My companion had just resigned as civilian aide to the Secretary of War. He was then dean of the Howard University law school and had been the first Negro to sit (though in the distant Virgin Islands) as a judge of the United States federal bench. My companion, William H. Hastie, has since been appointed governor of the Virgin Islands by President Truman. 

    We managed to get as far as a table by the window when a waiter came over and told me I was wanted on the phone. The manager was waiting for me outside the door. “Is that a colored man with you?” he asked. When I confessed it was, he told me that he would not be served. I replied that as a member I insisted on service for my guest and returned to the table. The insistence didn’t do much good. We sat for an hour talking, but not a glass of water was served us. 

    I tried to make a formal protest but could not get the twenty-five signatures required to call a special meeting. Only ten of my fellow newspapermen were willing to sign. I resigned from the club. 114/132-133

Saturday, September 21, 2019

1949

__________ 

“There is only one thing worse than one nation having the atomic bomb – that’s two nations having it.” 

Harold C. Urey, Nobel Prize winner

__________ 



The Soviet Union becomes the second member of the atomic bomb club.

 

January 20: Harry S. Truman is sworn in as president, for a full term. Goldman writes: “On orders from the White House, for the first time in American history Negroes were invited to the top social events of the Inaugural.” (1/91-92) 

 In his Inaugural Address, Truman introduced what came to be known as the “Point Four” program. Much of the money would come from the United States, but it would be co-operative and carried out through the U.N. 

“Our aim,” the president summarized, “should be to help the free peoples of the world, through their own efforts, to produce more food, more clothing, more materials for housing, and more mechanical power to lighten their burdens. … Only by helping the least fortunate of its members to help themselves can the human family achieve the decent, satisfying life that is the right of all people.”

 

Soon, more than 2,000 Americans would be “explaining sewage disposal or more efficient ways to teach reading” in far corners of the globe, “starting rivulets of change down unpredictable centuries.” 

One administrator of the program would later explain, “What makes Point 4 different from the ordinary concept of economic aid and makes it so infinitely appealing is that it emphasizes the distribution of knowledge rather than of money.” (1/94) 

In the months after Truman was sworn in for a full term, prices were going down. “The nickel beer returned to Manhattan, the $1.99 shirt to Kansas City, and a Des Moines newspaper discovered that a basket of groceries which cost $4.19 in 1948 could be bought now for $3.29.” (1/95) 

Meanwhile, Goldman explains, the Truman administration had given Chiang Kai-shek and his government more than $2 billion dollars; and that government was still failing. “The only alternative open to the United States was full-scale intervention on behalf of a Government,” said Secretary of State Acheson, “which had lost the confidence of its own troops and its own people.” (1/98) 


*

 January 21: Writing on the day after Truman gave his Inaugural Address, I.F. Stone was not impressed: 

    I still believe sheer economic necessity must move us toward an end of the Cold War. But I must say that my belief was badly shaken by Mr. Truman’s inaugural address, which left me sick at heart. It was shallow, naive, childishly arrogant, and self-righteous, a call for war thinly masked as a pledge of peace. 114/58

 

    The only conclusion one can draw is that Mr. Truman believes other people should be ‘free to govern themselves as they see fit’ – so long as they see fit to see as we see fit.

 

    This is a dangerous doctrine. It would mean that we set ourselves up to police the world. The USA is rich and strong but not rich and strong enough for that.

 

    “The prose was bad, the political analysis puerile, and the effect poisonous,” he added. 114/58-59, 70


* 

February: A growing fear of communism grips the people of the United States. Francis Cardinal Spellman appears, 

in the pulpit of Saint Patrick’s Cathedral to speak one of the most passionate sermons ever delivered from an American pulpit. America was in imminent danger of “Communist conquest and annihilation….Are we, the American people, the tools and the fools for which the communists take us?” The situation called for an immediate end of all “ostrich-like actions and pretenses, particularly in halting the Communist floodings of our own land.”

 

Previously, the Catechetical Guild of St. Paul had distributed a comic-strip pamphlet called Is This Tomorrow? In it, Communist mobs were depicted as attacking Saint Patrick’s with torches and nailing Cardinal Spellman to the door. (1/131)

 

* 

March 8: At around 6:30 p.m., Irving Feiner mounts a soapbox at the corner of South McBride and Harrison Streets, in Syracuse, New York. A student at Syracuse University, Feiner will later admit he was “a contentious young man.” But he is there to promote a leftist rally to be held at a nearby hotel.

 

The police later insisted that Feiner urged blacks to take up arms against whites. He attacked the mayor, local politicians, and the American Legion. (For the rest of his life, he would deny that he called President Harry S. Truman a bum, insisting that if he had meant to attack Truman, he would have used stronger language than that.)

 

Even the size of the crowd that gathered ended up in dispute. Police thought there were 75 to 80 whites and blacks. Lawyers for Mr. Feiner would later suggest that the number was more like 25 or 30. The sidewalks were blocked, and police felt the crowd was becoming “restive.” Several listeners heckled the young student, and at least one man threatened him.

 

Saying he feared a riot, a police officer twice asked Mr. Feiner to get down from the box. He refused and was arrested on a misdemeanor charge of disorderly conduct. Found guilty by a judge, he was sentenced to 30 days in jail.

 

Feiner, and free speech groups eventually appealed his case all the way to the U.S. Supreme Court. (See: January 1951).

 

Feiner had dropped out of high school to join the U.S. Army and go off to Europe to fight the Nazis. He was attending college on the G.I. Bill at the time of his arrest. 

 

* 

May 12: Israel becomes the 59th member of the United Nations. The vote to admit is 37-12. Six Arab nations immediately walk out in protest. They insist Israel has not complied with a U.N. resolution requiring for an international regime in Jerusalem and repatriation of Arab refugees.

 

* 

I could “vent my frustrations with being discriminated against.” 

George Taliaferro, star running back for Indiana University, is drafted by the Chicago Bears in the thirteenth round. 

What makes his selection historic is that Taliaferro is African American, the first player of his race drafted by an NFL team. 

He has already experienced steady racism at IU, where he and other African American players are forbidden to live in a dorm, eat in the cafeteria or swim in the university pool. In 1945 he helps Indiana win it’s only undisputed Big Ten championship ever. (It was called the Western Conference in those days.) In the days of two-way players in football, he lines up variously at halfback, quarterback, defensive back, and punts for Indiana, winning team MVP in 1948. 

“The thing I liked most about football was hitting people,” he told an interviewer long after he retired. “It allowed me to vent my frustrations with being discriminated against in the United States.” 

Taliaferro never expected to be drafted by the NFL; so he had already signed with the Los Angeles Dons of the All-American Football Conference by the time the draft took place. The Dons paid him a $4,000 bonus. 

George Halas, the coach of the Bears, said he was sorry to lose Taliaferro, because he felt he was the first black player “I’ve felt could make the team.” 

Taliaferro never believed that, bemoaning the reluctance of pro football to integrate. “The thing that bothers me to this day,” Taliaferro once said, “is that I can name for you any number – hundreds – of African-American players who could have played in the National Football League.” 

     The All-American Football Conference and the NFL merged in 1950 and Taliaferro went on to play in the NFL for six years, earning All-Pro honors three times.

 

* 

     Another athlete is having a particularly good year: Esther Williams, an actress, and former Olympic hopeful in a swimming pool. She had made the U.S. Olympic team at age 17, in 1940, but World War II put an end to any thought of the Games that year, and again, four years later. 

     Instead, she won fame swimming in Hollywood pools. By 1949, she had become one of Hollywood’s top ten most bankable stars – gracing multiple movies – and swimming her way into viewers’ hearts. As The New York Times later explained,  

Ms. Williams once estimated that she had swum 1,250 miles for the cameras. In a bathing suit, she was a special kind of all-American girl: tall, lithe, breathtakingly attractive and unpretentious. She begged MGM for serious nonswimming roles, but the studio’s response was, in effect, “If it ain’t broke, don’t fix it.” … Her only dry-land box-office success was “Take Me Out to the Ball Game” … with Ms. Williams as the owner of a baseball team whose players included Frank Sinatra and Gene Kelly (although even in that film, she was seen briefly in a swimming pool).

 

     The film critic Pauline Kael would eventually sum up the young actor’s greatest appeal: “Esther Williams had one contribution to make to movies – her magnificent athletic body. And for over 10 years MGM made the most of it, keeping her in clinging, wet bathing suits and hoping the audience would shiver.” 

     Out of the pool, in the real world, Williams was married four times, mostly badly. At 17, before she rose to fame, she wed for the first time, “to Leonard Kovner, a pre-med student whom she supported by working as a stock girl at a fancy department store.” When that marriage ended badly, Kovner demanded $1,500, all the money she had saved, before he would agree to a divorce. Her second try, to singer Ben Gage, lasted thirteen years, and brought her three children. “According to Ms. Williams, Mr. Gage frittered away $10 million of her money on alcohol, gambling and failed business ventures. He also neglected to pay taxes and left her in hock to the Internal Revenue Service for $750,000 by the time they divorced in 1959.” 

     A decade later, she married Fernando Lamas, an Argentine-born actor and director. He provided Esther with money, for a change. But he refused to allow her children to live with them – or even come to the wedding. After Lamas died, she married once more, when she was 73.

     Below, three shots of the actor:



 

* 

Clem Walker and Leone Baxter, his second wife, managed sixty California campaigns, including referendum votes between 1933 and 1959. They won fifty-five. 

In 1949 they offered their services to the American Medical Association and helped block President Truman’s health-insurance plan. Theodore H. White describes their principles: “The first of these…was unspoken: ‘Politics is too important to be left to politicians.’ The second is simpler; ‘More Americans like corn than caviar.’ The third is still operational: either party, or any legislature, can be taken over for a specific purpose if enough muscle, enough volunteers, enough grass-roots strength can be coaxed out of the ballot boxes.

 

And there were corollaries to these basic principles: the best kind of campaign is an attack campaign; in any campaign, an enemy has to be invented against whom the voters can be warned; issues are to be few, but must be clear—and must confront the voter with an emotional decision; the independent vote is critical in a close election, and once the party is captured by a nomination, the independent must be the target of all suasion and P. R.

 

Lastly, Whitaker and Baxter believed that a campaign must have an inner rhythm, a pace, a timing that would capture the attention of the news system, both print and electronic.

 

“Whitaker and Baxter were themselves sublimely uninterested in any substantive issues. Their ethics were those of a skilled lawyer who does his best to win a case. They could, for their fee, deliver a tailor-made campaign for anybody or any cause; and they usually won.” (Breach of Faith, p. 55; slightly modified) 

 

* 

July 22: I. F. Stone offers praise for Justice Frank Murphy in his column: FDR, he says, wanted “a judge who could not be convinced that the Founding Fathers wrote the Constitution especially to protect Amalgamated Can from having to pay its charladies a living wage.” 

    “Mr. Justice Murphy was no rubber stamp. He was a man of warm heart and saintly spirit, who cared deeply about justice and about liberty. … None saw more truly than he the terrible racistic implications of what was done to the West Coast Japanese. None was readier to speak for the hated and the hunted, whether it was the anti-Catholic Jehovah’s Witnesses or the fugitive Eisler.” 114/52


 * 

August 29: The Soviet Union explodes its first atomic bomb, catching the U.S. by surprise. Goldman writes: 

American scientists had believed the Russians would not get the atomic bomb until at least 1952, some even saying it would not be before 1955. In Chicago Harold C. Urey, the Nobel Prize leader in atomic research, managed to phrase what so many Americans were feeling. He was “flattened” by the announcement, Urey told reporters. “There is only one thing worse than one nation having the atomic bomb – that’s two nations having it.” (1-100)

 

Harold Taylor, president of Sarah Lawrence, saw that fear of communism was warping American thought. He got off a perfect definition of a patriotic American as “one who tells all his secrets without being asked, believes we should go to war with Russia, holds no political view without prior consultation with his employer, does not ask for increases in salary or wages, and is in favor of peace, universal military training, brotherhood, and baseball.” (1/101) 

Goldman notes: “the shocks of 1949 were so severe that all old alignments were being shattered.” (1/127) 

…Albert Einstein went on television, the simple sweater jacket, the scraggly gray hair, the childlike face with the brilliant eyes all adding to the aura of an otherworldly wisdom beyond the power of ordinary mortals. With the order of President Truman to produce an H-bomb, Einstein said, radioactive poisoning of the atmosphere and hence annihilation of any life on earth has been brought within the range of technical possibilities. … General annihilation beckons.”

 

* 

September 6: Howard Unruh, a World War II veteran, who had seen extensive combat, goes for a 20-minute stroll through his neighborhood in Camden, New Jersey, and shoots and kills thirteen people, including three children. Suffering from paranoid schizophrenia, he never stands trial. At the time of the rampage, Howard was living at home with his mother. The New York Times describes what happened: 

On the morning of Tuesday, Sept. 6, 1949, Mrs. Unruh fixed her son a breakfast of fried eggs and cereal. Moments later, she was astonished to see him threatening her with a wrench. She ran from the apartment to a friend’s home. 


At 9:20 a.m., Mr. Unruh, a slender 6-footer, wearing a brown tropical suit, white shirt and bow tie, stepped into the sun-splashed street and walked to a shoemaker’s shop on his block. He pulled out a 9 millimeter German Luger pistol he had purchased at a Philadelphia gun shop in January 1947 and pointed it at the owner, John Pilarchik, 27.

“I had leveled the gun at him, neither of us said nothing, and I pulled the trigger,” Mr. Unruh told a psychiatrist a month later. “He had a funny look on his face, staggered back and fell to the floor. I realized then he was still alive, so I fired into his head.”

 

Next, he went to a tailor shop looking for the owner, Thomas Zegrino, but instead shot the man’s wife, Helga, 28, who was there alone.

 

     Then he entered a barber shop and shot Orris Smith, 6, who was astride a white hobby horse, getting his hair cut as his mother, Catherine, sat beside him.

 

The barber, Clark Hoover, 33, was the next victim. In his confession, Mr. Unruh told how the man had “dodged around the barber chair, making it difficult for me to get a clear shot, but I finally hit him, walked over and then shot into his head.”

 

Then Mr. Unruh approached a tavern, but the owner, Frank Engel, having heard the shots, locked the door and fled with his patrons to the rear as Mr. Unruh shot into the bar.

 

Next, Mr. Unruh fired into an apartment window and shot Thomas Hamilton, a 2-year-old, in the head. After shooting into a restaurant, he fired through the window of a passing automobile and hit Alvin Day, 24, a television repairman.

 

Mr. Engel, who owned a pistol, shot Mr. Unruh in the hip from an upper-floor window of the tavern building, but Mr. Unruh seemed not to notice the wound. 


Having reloaded his pistol, he went to a drugstore owned by Maurice Cohen, 40, whose family had argued with Mr. Unruh over his using the Cohens’s gate to take a shortcut from his home to the street. As Mr. Unruh entered, Jason Hutton, 45, an insurance agent, was emerging. Mr. Unruh shot him in the head.


Mr. Cohen fled to the roof of his apartment above the drugstore as his wife, Rose, 38, hid in a closet and pushed their son Charles, 12, into another closet. Mr. Unruh shot Mr. Cohen in the back, sending him plunging to the street. He also shot Ms. Cohen, firing through the closet door, and Minnie Cohen, 63, the druggist’s mother, as she was trying to call the police from a bedroom. Charles Cohen was unharmed.


Over the next few minutes, Mr. Unruh shot Helen Matlack Wilson, 37; her son, John, 9; and her mother, Emma Matlack, 68, who were in a car stopped at a red light. He also wounded Charles Peterson, 18, who had approached Mr. Hutton’s body outside the drug store, unaware that the gunman was still on the scene.


On his final stop, Mr. Unruh broke into a home and wounded Madeline Harrie, 36, and her son Armand, 16.

 

    Unruh then retreated to his mother’s apartment. Fifty police converged, and opened fire with machine guns, shotguns, and pistols. At one point, a city official phoned the apartment and Howard answered. 

Mr. Buxton [the Camden official] asked Mr. Unruh how many people he had killed. 


“I don’t know, I haven’t counted,” he said. “Looks like a pretty good score.” 


“Why are you killing people?” Mr. Buxton asked. 


“I don’t know,” Mr. Unruh replied.

 

    He was driven out into the open, after tear gas was fired into the building. He surrendered without further incident, and remained in state custody, in facilities for the criminally insane, for the rest of his life. He died at age 88, in October, 2009.

 

* 

September 25: Pro football is a different kind of game in 1949. In the season opener for the Chicago Bears, they hold the Green Bay Packers to -7 yards passing, when three different players combine to throw 13 passes, for zero completions, with one quarterback sack. 

    The Bears turn the ball over three times, which would be terrible by modern standards. The Packers return the favor, only double, losing the ball six times, and the game 17-0. Attendance is 25,571.

 

* 

Baseball season: For the second time in her career, Doris Sams is chosen as MVP of the All-American Girls Professional Baseball League (founded in 1943). Highlights of her career will include leading the league with a record twelve homeruns in one season and hitting over .300, in each of her last four seasons, in a row. Sams was also a pitcher, and had one perfect game, another no hitter, and won a third epic duel, going all the way in a 1-0 win, against the Rockford Peaches, in 22 innings. 

    Another star of the league is Dorothy Kamenshek, the first baseman (“basewoman”) for the Peaches. Twice, during her ten seasons, she led the league in batting average, and was chosen for seven All-Star teams. “She had the whole package,” another player recalled. “She could hit with power, she could lay the bunt down and steal the base. She was a great first baseman – she could go off the ground three feet and grab it, or dig it out of the dirt. She was a tough lady, and she was as smart as they come.” 

    Skirts were a required part of the uniform for the women, but Kamenshek wasn’t afraid to slide. She stole 109 bases in one season. “We got used to it,” she once said. “In the spring, we’re always hoping we’d develop calluses. If you got your skin toughened up, you were pretty lucky most of year.”

 

* 

October 7: George Blanda knocks down a 29-yard field goal in the first quarter of a Chicago Bears win, 17-7, over the Chicago Cardinals. He will go on to play 26 seasons, first with the Bears – not counting 1959, when he retired – then jumping to the American Football League in 1960, with the Houston Oilers. In the early years, the AFL will prove to be a pass happy league, with the Oilers winning the first two championships, and Blanda throwing 36 touchdown passes in 1961, and then 42 interceptions the following season. 

    Before he is done, Blanda will play in 340 games, make 335 field goals, attempt 641, and in an era of the straight-ahead kicking style, hit on only eight of 38 attempts, fifty yards or longer. Before he hangs up his cleats, he will score 2,002 points, a record at the time he retired. 

    “He never got older,” The Sporting News once wrote. “He just got better. He was the epitome of the grizzled veteran, the symbol of everlasting youth.”

 

* 

October 31: Unimpressed with the workings of the national legislature, I.F. Stone remarks, “There are areas of knowledge in which I am as illiterate as an aborigine or a congressman.” 

    “There are no Galileos here to disprove what every respectable idiot takes for granted,” he adds. 

    “The political leadership of our time is aware of the philosophic implications of the new world, but basically – and this applies to Moscow as much as to Washington – it is rallying mankind for a new war on the basis of absolutes as spurious as those of the holy wars of the past.”  114/117-120

 

* 

December 22: Stone warns of a drift toward the suppression of free speech, noting, “But you cannot have freedom without the risk of its abuse. The men who wrote the Bill of Rights were willing to take their chances on freedom.” 114/110